Dual Citizenship and Constitutional Rights in Nigeria

Nigeria, a nation rich in cultural diversity and a burgeoning diaspora, has a nuanced relationship with dual citizenship. While many countries grapple with the concept, Nigeria’s legal framework, primarily the 1999 Constitution (as amended), attempts to strike a balance between acknowledging its citizens’ global connections and upholding national loyalty. This complex interplay between dual citizenship and constitutional rights presents both opportunities and challenges for individuals and the nation alike.

This extensive blog post delves deep into the intricacies of dual citizenship in Nigeria, exploring its constitutional basis, the rights and obligations of dual citizens, the challenges and controversies that arise, and the broader implications for national development and human rights.

1. Understanding Dual Citizenship: A Global Perspective

Before dissecting the Nigerian context, it’s crucial to grasp the general concept of dual citizenship. Dual citizenship, or dual nationality, refers to the legal status of an individual who is a citizen of two or more countries simultaneously. This status can be acquired in various ways:

Jus Soli (Right of Soil): Citizenship by birth in a particular territory, regardless of the parents’ nationality. Countries like the United States and Canada largely follow this principle.
Jus Sanguinis (Right of Blood): Citizenship by descent from a parent who is a citizen of that country, regardless of the child’s place of birth. Many European and African nations, including Nigeria, primarily adhere to this.
Naturalization: The process by which a foreign national acquires citizenship of another country after fulfilling specific residency and other requirements.
Marriage: In some countries, marriage to a citizen can expedite the naturalization process.
Investment: A growing trend where citizenship is granted in exchange for significant financial investment in a country.

The global landscape of dual citizenship is diverse. Some countries strictly prohibit it, requiring individuals to renounce previous nationalities upon acquiring a new one. Others, like Nigeria, adopt a more permissive stance, albeit with certain restrictions. The primary drivers behind the increasing acceptance of dual citizenship often include:

Globalization and Mobility: Increased migration for economic, educational, and social reasons.
Diaspora Engagement: Countries seeking to maintain ties with their emigrants and leverage their human and financial capital for national development.
Human Rights Considerations: Acknowledging an individual’s right to maintain connections to their heritage and family.

2. The Constitutional Framework of Dual Citizenship in Nigeria

The legal foundation for dual citizenship in Nigeria is primarily enshrined in Chapter III of the 1999 Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria (as amended), specifically sections 25, 26, 27, and 28. These sections outline the different modes of acquiring Nigerian citizenship and the conditions under which dual citizenship is permitted or restricted.

2.1. Modes of Acquiring Nigerian Citizenship:

The Constitution provides three main avenues for acquiring Nigerian citizenship:

Citizenship by Birth (Section 25): This is the most straightforward and fundamental form of citizenship.
- Section 25(1)(a): Every person born in Nigeria before or on the date of independence (October 1, 1960) whose parents or any of whose grandparents belonged to an indigenous community of Nigeria.
- Section 25(1)(b): Every person born in Nigeria after the date of independence, whose parents or any of whose grandparents is a citizen of Nigeria.
- Section 25(1)(c): Every person born outside Nigeria whose parents are citizens of Nigeria. This is the jus sanguinis principle, emphasizing descent.
Crucially, citizenship by birth is considered inalienable and cannot be easily revoked. This is a significant point when discussing dual citizenship.
Citizenship by Registration (Section 26): This applies to:
- Section 26(1): Any woman who is or has been married to a citizen of Nigeria.
- Section 26(2): Every person of full age and capacity born outside Nigeria any of whose grandparents is a citizen of Nigeria.
To acquire citizenship by registration, an applicant must satisfy the President that they are of good character, have shown a clear intention of their desire to be domiciled in Nigeria, and have taken the oath of allegiance.
Citizenship by Naturalization (Section 27): This is the most stringent pathway for foreign nationals. It requires an applicant to:
- Be of full age and capacity.
- Be of good character.
- Have shown a clear intention to be domiciled in Nigeria.
- Be capable of contributing to the well-being of Nigeria.
- Have resided in Nigeria continuously for a period of 15 years immediately preceding the application, or for 12 months immediately preceding the application, and during the 20 years immediately preceding that period of 12 months, resided in Nigeria for periods amounting in the aggregate to not less than 15 years.
- Have taken the oath of allegiance.
- Have a certificate from the Governor of the state where they reside confirming their acceptance by the community.

2.2. The Nuance of Section 28: Dual Citizenship

Section 28 of the 1999 Constitution directly addresses dual citizenship and is the cornerstone of Nigeria’s policy on the matter. It states:

Section 28(1): “Subject to the other provisions of this section, a person shall forfeit forthwith his Nigerian citizenship if, not being a citizen of Nigeria by birth, he acquires or retains the citizenship or nationality of a country, other than Nigeria, of which he is not a citizen by birth.”

Section 28(2): “Any registration of a person as a citizen of Nigeria or the grant of a certificate of naturalization to a person who is a citizen of a country other than Nigeria at the time of such registration or grant sh¹all, if he is not a citizen by birth of that other country, be conditional upon effective renuncia²tion of the citizenship or nationality of that other country within a peri³od of twelve months from the date of such registration or grant.”

Interpretation and Implications:

Citizens by Birth CAN hold Dual Citizenship: The key takeaway from Section 28(1) is that a person who is a Nigerian citizen by birth is not required to forfeit their Nigerian citizenship if they acquire or retain the citizenship of another country. This means that Nigerians born in Nigeria (or born abroad to Nigerian parents) can legally hold a second nationality without losing their Nigerian status. This provision is a significant departure from earlier, more restrictive interpretations and reflects a growing recognition of the diaspora’s importance.
Citizens by Registration or Naturalization MUST Renounce (with an exception): Section 28(2) places a stricter condition on those who become Nigerian citizens through registration or naturalization. Such individuals are generally required to renounce their other citizenship(s) (unless that other citizenship was acquired by birth in that other country) within 12 months of being granted Nigerian citizenship. This clause is intended to ensure primary loyalty to Nigeria for those who actively choose to become Nigerian citizens.

2.3. Legal Evolution and Judicial Pronouncements:

The interpretation and application of Section 28 have been subject to judicial scrutiny over the years. Early interpretations sometimes created ambiguities, particularly regarding the eligibility of dual citizens for public office. However, landmark judgments have clarified the position, affirming the right of Nigerian citizens by birth to hold dual nationality and, importantly, to hold elective public offices, provided they meet other constitutional requirements.

A notable case is Ogbeide v. Arigbe-Osula (2004) 12 NWLR (Pt. 886) 138, where the Court of Appeal unequivocally held that a Nigerian citizen by birth does not lose their Nigerian citizenship by acquiring the citizenship of another country, and such dual citizenship does not disqualify them from contesting elections into the National Assembly. This ruling has been instrumental in shaping the understanding of dual citizenship rights in Nigeria.

3. Constitutional Rights and Dual Citizens: A Deep Dive

The constitutional rights of a Nigerian dual citizen are, in principle, identical to those of a single Nigerian citizen. Chapter IV of the 1999 Constitution outlines the Fundamental Rights of every citizen. These include, but are not limited to:

Right to Life (Section 33): No person shall be deprived intentionally of his life, save in execution of the sentence of a court in respect of a criminal offence of which he has been found guilty in Nigeria.
Right to Dignity of Human Person (Section 34): Every individual is entitled to respect for the dignity of his person, and no person shall be subjected to torture or to inhuman or degrading treatment.
Right to Personal Liberty (Section 35): Every person shall be entitled to his personal liberty and no person shall be deprived of such liberty save in accordance with a procedure permitted by law.
Right to Fair Hearing (Section 36): Every person shall be entitled to a fair hearing within a reasonable time by a court or other tribunal established by law.
Right to Private and Family Life (Section 37): The privacy of citizens, their homes, correspondence, telephone conversations and telegraphic communications is hereby guaranteed and protected.
Right to Freedom of Thought, Conscience and Religion (Section 38): Every person shall be entitled to freedom of thought, conscience and religion, including freedom to change his religion or belief, and freedom (either alone or in community with others, and in public or in private) to manifest and propagate his religion or belief in worship, teaching, practice and observance.
Right to Freedom of Expression and the Press (Section 39): Every person shall be entitled to freedom of expression, including freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart ideas and information without interference.
Right to Peaceful Assembly and Association (Section 40): Every person shall be entitled to assemble freely and associate with other persons, and in particular he may form or belong to any political party, trade union or any other association for the protection of his interests.
Right to Freedom of Movement (Section 41): Every citizen of Nigeria is entitled to move freely throughout Nigeria and to reside in any part thereof, and no citizen of Nigeria shall be expelled from Nigeria or refused entry thereto or exit therefrom. This is particularly relevant for dual citizens who frequently travel.
Right to Freedom from Discrimination (Section 42): A citizen of Nigeria of a particular community, ethnic group, place of origin, sex, religion or political opinion shall not, by reason only that he is such a person:- (a) be subjected either expressly by, or in the practical application of, any law in force in Nigeria or any executive or administrative action of the government to disabilities or restrictions to which citizens of Nigeria of other communities, ethnic groups, places of origin, sex, religions or political opinions are not made subject; or
(b) be accorded either expressly by, or in the practical application of, any law in force in Nigeria or any executive or administrative action of the government any privilege or advantage that is not accorded to citizens of Nigeria of other communities, ethnic groups, places of origin, sex, religions or political opinions.
Right to Acquire and Own Immovable Property Anywhere in Nigeria (Section 43): Subject to the provisions of this Constitution, every citizen of Nigeria shall have the right to acquire and own immovable property anywhere in Nigeria.

Specific Considerations for Dual Citizens:

While these rights apply equally, certain aspects of dual citizenship intersect with these rights in interesting ways:

Right to Vote and Be Voted For: As established by judicial precedent, citizens by birth with dual nationality retain their right to vote and to contest elections for various public offices, including the Presidency, governorships, and legislative seats. This ensures their full political participation in Nigeria.
Right to Hold Public Office: The Constitution generally permits citizens by birth with dual nationality to hold public office. However, specific provisions, particularly for certain high-level appointments, may require closer scrutiny of loyalty or potential conflicts of interest. For instance, while a citizen by birth can be a legislator with dual nationality, some may argue that certain security or judicial roles might demand singular allegiance. This remains an area where administrative discretion and evolving interpretations may play a role, even if the constitution broadly permits it.
Right to Freedom of Movement: Dual citizens typically benefit from enhanced global mobility, utilizing passports from both countries for easier travel and visa-free access to a wider range of destinations.
Right to Property Ownership: Dual citizens have the same rights to acquire and own property in Nigeria as any other Nigerian citizen.

4. Obligations of Dual Citizens in Nigeria

While enjoying extensive rights, dual citizens in Nigeria also bear obligations, both to Nigeria and to their other country of citizenship.

Loyalty to Nigeria: The fundamental obligation of any Nigerian citizen, including dual nationals, is loyalty to the Federal Republic of Nigeria. This is enshrined in the National Pledge and the Oath of Allegiance. While dual loyalty is often a concern, it is generally understood that a citizen’s primary loyalty should lie with the country they are currently residing in or for which they are performing official duties.
Compliance with Nigerian Laws: Dual citizens, like all residents, are subject to Nigerian laws while in the country. This includes obeying traffic laws, respecting human rights, and fulfilling civic duties.
Payment of Taxes: Dual citizens are obligated to pay taxes on income earned in Nigeria, in accordance with Nigerian tax laws. The issue of double taxation can arise if both countries of citizenship claim tax jurisdiction over the individual’s global income. Nigeria has double taxation treaties with several countries to mitigate this, but it’s crucial for dual citizens to understand their tax obligations in both jurisdictions.
National Service (if applicable): While Nigeria does not currently have mandatory military service, if such a requirement were to be instituted, dual citizens would likely be subject to it, potentially creating conflicts with military obligations in their other country of citizenship.
Avoiding Conflicts of Interest: For dual citizens aspiring to or holding sensitive public offices, there is an inherent responsibility to avoid situations that could lead to conflicts of interest or compromise national security. This often necessitates careful consideration of the laws and policies of both countries.

5. Challenges and Controversies of Dual Citizenship in Nigeria

Despite the clear constitutional provisions and judicial pronouncements, dual citizenship in Nigeria continues to be a subject of discussion and, at times, controversy.

5.1. Perceived Conflict of Loyalty:

This is perhaps the most enduring concern. Critics argue that holding two nationalities inherently creates a conflict of loyalty, questioning how an individual can be fully committed to Nigeria while owing allegiance to another sovereign state. This often surfaces in debates about public office holders or individuals in sensitive national security roles. However, proponents argue that loyalty is not solely determined by citizenship status and that many dual citizens contribute significantly to Nigeria’s development through remittances, investment, and knowledge transfer.

5.2. Eligibility for Public Office:

While judicial pronouncements have largely settled the matter for citizens by birth, the question of eligibility for certain public offices for dual citizens occasionally resurfaces. For instance, some argue that key roles requiring utmost national security clearance or representing Nigeria on the international stage should ideally be held by individuals with singular Nigerian citizenship. This is often more a matter of perception and policy than strict constitutional prohibition for citizens by birth.

5.3. Administrative Hurdles and Bureaucracy:

For Nigerians seeking to formalize their dual citizenship status, or for foreigners seeking Nigerian citizenship by registration or naturalization, the administrative processes can be cumbersome and bureaucratic. This can lead to delays, frustration, and, in some cases, the inability to fully exercise their rights.

5.4. Data Collection and Tracking:

The Nigerian government faces challenges in accurately tracking and managing its dual citizen population. This can impact policy formulation, diaspora engagement strategies, and even census data.

5.5. Legal Technicalities and Interpretations:

While the core principle for citizens by birth is clear, nuanced interpretations of “citizen by birth” in the context of the other country’s citizenship can sometimes lead to legal complexities, particularly for individuals whose second citizenship was acquired through birth in a country that also applies jus sanguinis.

5.6. Socio-Economic Disparities:

The benefits of dual citizenship, such as easier international travel, access to diverse job markets, and better social services, are often more accessible to those with the financial means and opportunities to acquire a second nationality. This can inadvertently contribute to socio-economic disparities within the Nigerian population.

6. The Benefits and Drawbacks of Dual Citizenship for Nigeria

Dual citizenship, while presenting challenges, also offers significant advantages for Nigeria.

6.1. Advantages:

Increased Diaspora Engagement: Dual citizenship fosters stronger ties with the Nigerian diaspora, encouraging them to invest, remit funds, and contribute their skills and expertise to national development. The diaspora is a vital source of foreign exchange and human capital.
Brain Gain and Reverse Migration: It encourages skilled Nigerians living abroad to return and contribute to the economy, knowing they can retain their adopted nationality and the benefits associated with it. This helps mitigate brain drain.
Economic Investment and Remittances: Dual citizens are more likely to invest in Nigeria, acquire property, and send remittances, boosting the national economy.
Enhanced Global Mobility and Networks: Dual citizens often serve as bridges between Nigeria and other nations, facilitating trade, cultural exchange, and diplomatic relations. Their networks can open doors for Nigeria on the international stage.
Diverse Perspectives and Skills: The return of dual citizens often brings new ideas, work ethics, and global best practices, enriching various sectors of the Nigerian economy and society.
Tourism and Cultural Exchange: Easier travel for dual citizens can boost tourism and promote cultural exchange between Nigeria and other countries.

6.2. Disadvantages:

Potential for Divided Loyalties (Perception): As discussed, this remains a persistent concern, particularly in sensitive governmental and security roles.
Brain Drain (Initial Loss): While dual citizenship can facilitate “brain gain,” the initial emigration of skilled Nigerians to acquire foreign citizenship can be seen as a form of brain drain if they do not eventually return or actively contribute from abroad.
Complexity in Legal and Administrative Systems: Managing a dual citizen population can add complexity to legal, electoral, and administrative frameworks.
Security Concerns: In some cases, there might be concerns about the potential for individuals to exploit dual nationality for illicit activities or to evade justice. This, however, is not unique to dual citizens and applies to any individual.

7. Case Studies and Judicial Precedents

Beyond Ogbeide v. Arigbe-Osula, other judicial pronouncements and legal discussions have further illuminated the landscape of dual citizenship in Nigeria. While specific case details may be complex, the general trend in Nigerian jurisprudence has been to uphold the constitutional provisions, particularly the right of citizens by birth to hold dual nationality without forfeiture. These cases often revolve around challenges to the eligibility of candidates for political office based on their dual citizenship, with the courts consistently ruling in favor of the citizens by birth.

It is important to note that the judiciary plays a crucial role in interpreting the constitutional provisions and ensuring that the spirit of the law, which allows for dual citizenship for citizens by birth, is maintained.

8. The Future of Dual Citizenship in Nigeria: Recommendations and Prospects

The current constitutional framework for dual citizenship in Nigeria is relatively progressive for citizens by birth. However, there are areas where further clarification, streamlining, and policy adjustments could enhance its benefits and mitigate its challenges.

8.1. Recommendations:

Clearer Guidelines for Public Office: While the constitution broadly permits dual citizens by birth to hold public office, specific guidelines or a legislative framework could be developed for sensitive positions to address any lingering concerns about loyalty or conflict of interest, ensuring transparency and accountability.
Streamlining Administrative Processes: The process for acquiring Nigerian citizenship by registration or naturalization, and for verifying dual citizenship status, should be made more efficient, transparent, and user-friendly. This would reduce bureaucratic hurdles and encourage more engagement from the diaspora.
Public Awareness and Education: There is a need for greater public awareness and education campaigns to dispel misconceptions about dual citizenship, particularly regarding perceived conflicts of loyalty. Highlighting the benefits of diaspora engagement can foster a more inclusive national discourse.
Enhancing Data Management: The government should invest in robust data collection and management systems to accurately track and engage with its dual citizen population, both domestically and abroad.
Review of Renunciation Requirements: While Section 28(2) mandates renunciation for citizens by registration or naturalization (with the birth exception), a periodic review of this provision could be considered in light of evolving global citizenship trends and Nigeria’s national interests.
Strengthening Diaspora Commission: The Nigerians in Diaspora Commission (NiDCOM) plays a vital role in engaging the diaspora. Its mandate should be strengthened, and it should be adequately resourced to facilitate seamless interaction with dual citizens.
Protection of Rights Abroad: The Nigerian government should continue to advocate for and protect the rights of its dual citizens when they are in their other country of citizenship, ensuring consular assistance and diplomatic support where necessary.

8.2. Prospects:

The trend globally is towards greater acceptance of dual citizenship, recognizing its potential to strengthen ties with diasporas and leverage global human capital. Nigeria, with its vast and influential diaspora, stands to gain significantly from embracing a more open and streamlined approach. As the world becomes increasingly interconnected, dual citizenship can be a powerful tool for national development, fostering economic growth, promoting cultural exchange, and enhancing Nigeria’s global standing.

9. Conclusion

Dual citizenship in Nigeria is a complex yet fascinating aspect of its constitutional law, reflecting the nation’s historical trajectory, its diverse population, and its aspirations for global relevance. The 1999 Constitution, through Section 28, largely permits dual citizenship for those who acquire Nigerian citizenship by birth, while imposing stricter conditions on those who acquire it through registration or naturalization.

The implications of this legal framework are profound, impacting the fundamental rights and obligations of millions of Nigerians at home and abroad. While concerns about loyalty and political eligibility persist, judicial pronouncements have largely affirmed the rights of dual citizens by birth, paving the way for their full participation in the Nigerian socio-political landscape.

As Nigeria continues to navigate the complexities of a globalized world, a well-articulated and efficiently managed dual citizenship policy will be crucial for harnessing the immense potential of its diaspora, promoting national unity, and ensuring that all its citizens, regardless of their additional nationalities, can contribute meaningfully to the progress and prosperity of the Federal Republic of Nigeria. The journey towards a truly inclusive and globally integrated Nigeria is ongoing, and dual citizenship remains a key pillar in this national evolution.

Table of Contents